CDA Institute Blog: The Forum

  • Home
    Home This is where you can find all the blog posts throughout the site.
  • Categories
    Categories Displays a list of categories from this blog.
  • Tags
    Tags Displays a list of tags that have been used in the blog.
  • Bloggers
    Bloggers Search for your favorite blogger from this site.
  • Team Blogs
    Team Blogs Find your favorite team blogs here.
  • Login
    Login Login form

Roundtable Summary – The Warrior State: Pakistan in the Contemporary World

  • Font size: Larger Smaller
  • Print

A summary of a recent roundtable presentation by Dr. TV Paul.

The following is a summary of the CDA Institute roundtable on the subject of Dr. TV Paul’s recent book: “The Warrior State: Pakistan in the Contemporary World” (Oxford University Press, 2014), as presented by Dr. Paul, held in Ottawa on 31 January 2014. These roundtable discussions are held under the Chatham House Rule. This summary reflects the author’s perception of the discussion. The CDA Institute thanks Lockheed Martin for its generous sponsorship of the 2014 Round-​table Discussion Series. If you would like to contribute to the discussion on this topic, comment below, or submit a blog post for consideration to this blog’s editor at This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

As American combat troops continue to withdraw from Afghanistan until the end of 2014, American drone strikes target Pakistani Taliban militant forces in the Federally Administered Tribal Areas, and relations with neighbouring rival India remain strained, Pakistan’s status as a state of enormous geostrategic significance will continue well into the foreseeable future. For this reason, in-​depth analysis of the country’s military, political, and economical structures and priorities is crucial to implementing effective policy strategies to aid in Pakistan’s security concerns.

Reasoning for the presentation was introduced at the outset. Pakistan’s importance as a pivotal state in South Asia was highlighted, and it was noted that many observers describe what is going on in the country, but that few do concrete analysis or conduct any social science to better understand the country’s political and economic difficulties. The presentation sought to discuss and critically analyze Pakistan’s insecurity predicament using developed arguments in historical sociology, international relations, and comparative politics.

Specifically, the presentation discussed a theory by the late sociologist Charles Tilly which argues that many modern European liberal democracies have come to exist through centuries of taxation and political concessions: essentially, war-​making as state-​making. The case of Pakistan is presented as an exception to this theory, at least thus far in its sixty-​six year history. Throughout this time the country has had intense military preparedness, four wars, and military rule for over half of its existence (with democratic interludes). Yet, Pakistan remains a case of international terrorism, Islamic extremism, and political instability and is likely to maintain this trajectory due to its geostrategic location.

Therein lies the key argument presented to understand Pakistan’s economic shortcomings and political and security challenges: The state suffers from a ‘geostrategic curse’. This condition is both a blessing and a curse much like a ‘resource curse’ or ‘foreign aid curse’. Indeed, a massive amount of foreign financial support ($73 billion between 1960 and 2012) due to Pakistan’s geostrategic positioning between Afghanistan and India has been most welcome. However, the aid has been disproportionately allocated to military spending to fund Pakistan’s desire to attain strategic parity and compete for status with India as well as to counter an influx of militant insurgency in Pakistan’s tribal areas due to Afghanistan’s long-​lasting instability. Thus, this ‘curse’ has incentivized military expenditure over economic development. It was noted that Egypt suffers from a similar condition.

The presentation concluded with the assertion that time alone will not solve this problem. Sixty-​six years may seem like a short time period to revamp a state’s political and economic structures, but similar cases in East Asia and Latin America did not have the same difficulties in a similar time period. The Pakistani government believes that deep-​rooted social or economic reforms, including land reforms, are too risky and has resulted in a focus on military-​first policies and worst-​case assumptions concerning security issues. This has ensured that trade or economic development policies have been secondary to military expenditure.

The roundtable then moved into an extensive and fruitful discussion. Topics of particular focus were Afghanistan’s role in South Asia’s rivalry, the potential instability of new Pakistani nuclear delivery systems, Pakistan’s approach to counter-​terrorism, and whether foreign aid to Pakistan should be conditional to social developments within the country. To a lesser extent, the role of leadership theory and water wars between India and Pakistanwere touched on as well. The session ended with an interesting series of suggestions for creating more robust channels of communication between Pakistan and its regional neighbours, particularly India.

in Roundtable and Event Summaries Hits: 2104 0 Comments
0

Comments

  • No comments made yet. Be the first to submit a comment

Leave your comment

Guest Friday, 24 February 2017
Home | Blog: The Forum | Roundtable Summary – The Warrior State: Pakistan in the Contemporary World

Support Us

The CDA Institute is seeking donors and corporate sponsors for Fiscal Year 2016/​2017 to support its research activities, events and publications, which are disseminated amongst various audiences. Read More

CDA Institute

Created in 1987, the CDA Institute is a charitable and non-​partisan research organization whose mandate is to promote informed public debate on national security and defence issues and the vital role played by the Canadian Armed Forces in our society.

Contact Us

Conference of Defence Associations/​
CDA Institute
151 Slater Street, Suite 412A
Ottawa, Ontario K1P 5H3
Canada

Telephone: +1 (613) 2369903